Him and his mum
A word about Tony Robinson’s brave documentary Me and My Mum on Channel 4 on Monday, which we watched last night. It’s part of the channel’s The Trouble With Old People season, the sort of thing they do well, and, as ever, the “money shot” (and I call it this with heavy irony), where Tony cries and puts his hand up to the camera to stop filming, was repeated endelessly in trails leading up to transmission. It’s clear, to the media-literate among us, that a programme isn’t going to get better than this. And indeed, this was the most overtly emotional moment, but the film itself offered so much more than the spectacle of the bloke off of Time Team blubbing. He set out to make a documentary about our disgraceful treatment of old people in this country, both politically and personally (the government grant for those that look after their own elderly or ailing parents is minimal compared to, say, that of a foster parent, and with the ongoing pensions crisis, it’s clear that no provision is being made for the future, despite longer life expectancy), but of course it ended up being “about love”, as the director said off-camera.

Tony’s mum, 89-year-old Phyllis, was in a care home, on the road to dementia but still strikingly lit up by her only son’s presence and able to communicate sporadically. It was hard to watch her being lifted in and out of his car for what turned out to be her last day out – she clearly hated it, although whether it was the pain in her old bones or the fuss and indignity we can never know. Tony was conflicted about the situation. He felt guilty for doing what so many of us do: putting a parent in a home. However, his grown-up kids from his first marriage were obviously really cool with their gran and made visits themselves. (Indeed it was Tony’s daughter’s loving relationship with “Phyll” that broke him up for that shot.) When she developed pneumonia, wiping out her means of speaking, and Tony was advised to let her “slip away”, it felt intrusive to see the family around her bedside as she died, but at the same time, it was a worthwhile spectacle to hammer home the programme’s points. I had been slightly uncomfortable during the film by how many times the old people in question were spoken about as if they were not in the room. Obviously, they couldn’t communicate verbally themselves, but it just felt disrespectful to talk about them while they were still there.

In the end, it was an admirable piece of television. Robinson was a warm host, really genuine with the other elderly folk he met, comforting the wife of 84-year-old John, who, after a fall, was confined to hospital, confused. He was much more communicative than Phyll, however, and asked really pertinent questions of his loving twin daughters as they lied to him (“When you’re better, you’re coming home”). They moved him to a nursing home and within ten days . . . he was dead. This was the actual “money shot” – the door closing on John’s room, the echo of empty promises, the memory of his last question, “This isn’t permanent is it?”

How can we stand by and watch our own parents and relatives end up in these waiting rooms? Home care should be subsidised for those that can’t afford it. It happens to us all. Even the woman who ran Phyll’s care home kept half-joking about “taking the pills” when her time came. It’s not just about money, it’s also about attitude. Look at the old people playing indoor bowls in Sutton in their blazers. Active, socialised, likely to live longer, happier lives. We must not abandon our parents in old age. It’s up to us to keep our families together, I think, to encourage them to go on living, not hide them away, or forget about them.

I fear for Tony Robinson. Both parents died of forms of Alzheimer’s. He’s 59. I hope he’s getting enough fish oils.


4 thoughts on “Care

  1. Raw nerve.I’ve wrestled with this since early this morning. Having deliberately avoided the TV programme (call me a coward) I can’t comment on what was broadcast.I always thought that this would be the worry I would have for my mother but she was taken from us suddenly a couple of years ago (too damn young… early 50s). I know this sounds harsh but I never had any concerns for my father. He’s an alcoholic and I’m still angry. He’ll probably outlive us all. If it comes to it he will have to fend for himself – if he hasn’t already drunk the house away. [ oooh I’m sure the trained among you all will read everything into that paragraph šŸ™‚ ]Seriously he will have to fend for himself. Whatever about looking after 3 children I’m not ready to look after a drunk too.You ask “how can we stand by and watch”. I’m not sure that we do so willingly. I’m fortunate that the decision has been taken away from me. But my wife finds herself with two elderly parents and a growing dilemma. One is bipolar (or mad-cow disease as I call it) and the other is losing his hearing and has cardiac problems [ not helped by his mad wife šŸ™‚ ]. We really don’t know what we’ll do when it comes to caring for them. As it stands they can just about look after themselves. Would we take one (or both) of them into our home ? Fuckit if it really came down to it I suppose we would. But what about our primary responsibility our 3 kids ? What’s the alternative ? A nursing home ? Is there any other alternative ? Maybe standing by and watching is all we can do ? I hope not. I don’t have any answers. My dear grandmother was between home and a nursing home/hospital when my mum died. It would have broken my mum’s heart to see her deteriorate in the way she did. After (another) fall it was decided that she really couldn’t care for herself and needed 24-7 care. It broke my aunts heart and I hated going to that nursing home. I hated seeing her there and hated that I couldn’t do anything better for my own flesh & blood. We spoke. She was just waiting to die. Last time I met her she was in hospital (you guessed… another fall) and she berated me for not bringing my wife with me on a business trip to Paris. When she fell it wasn’t her funny bone that fractured. A couple of weeks later we lost Kate. (Her name was Mary but in a peculiar Irish way we couldn’t be having with using proper names now could we ?).It’s long I know. Some of it is probably wrong. I’m 40 soon. When I’m 80 I don’t want to break my kids hearts slowly. If I’m unfortunate enough to be stricken by dementia then please send me away to la-la land with the finest chemicals. That and cremation please. Close the door on your way out won’t you ?

  2. Caught the last two thirds of the programme. Really enjoyed it. Well, probably ‘enjoyed’ is the wrong word, but you probably know what I mean. Tony Robinson is a top bloke, like you say. As he said in the programme, most people have their own tale to tell about a granny who has ended up in a home (both of mine did and didn’t last long in them). Tony came to our school for a talk in 1989. I really like him. Baldrick in Blackadder 2 was of course the best Baldrick. I have to admit to getting slightly tired of ‘Time Team’ in recent years though. Sorry Balders.

  3. I thought it was absolutely excellent. Also big Tony R fan.Incidentally, has anyone read Alan Bennett’s “Untold Stories”? There’s a bit in there about his mother’s nursing home that is very powerful, mainly because he doesn’t make a judgement either way, just tells it like it is. Well worth a look.

Do leave a reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s